School choice is no longer a debate school leaders can simply choose to participate in. For families across the country, it is a growing reality.
Districts now offer online academies, alternative programs, career pathways, magnet programs, and schools within schools. We celebrate these options because not every student thrives in the same environment—and because creating more ways for students to succeed is good leadership.
But our commitment to choice is tested when the option is not ours.
An online program operated by our own district may be described as innovative and responsive. A charter school offering families another option may be described as a threat. When we launch something new, we call it meeting students’ needs. When someone else does, we may question whether it should exist at all.
That tension is understandable. Enrollment affects funding, staffing, programs, and the stability of a school corporation. Superintendents have a responsibility to protect the organizations they lead.
But we also have a responsibility to ask ourselves a harder question: Are our positions driven by what is best for students, or by who controls the option?
As lifelong traditional public educators, we have learned that school choice is like almost anything else: the closer we get to the people involved, the harder it becomes to dismiss them.
It is easy to have a strong opinion about “charter schools,” “private schools,” or “traditional public schools” as broad categories. It becomes harder when we visit classrooms, meet educators, talk with families, and see students thriving.
Research supports that experience. In a widely cited analysis of more than 500 studies, psychologists Thomas Pettigrew and Linda Tropp found that meaningful contact between groups generally reduces prejudice and changes how people view those they once considered outsiders. Proximity does not eliminate disagreement, but it makes stereotypes harder to maintain.
Our own experiences have confirmed that. We have met incredible educators in traditional public schools, public charter schools, and private schools. We have also seen ineffective practices in every one of those sectors. The label on the school tells us far less than we sometimes pretend it does.
Quality is not owned by any one kind of school.
The Indiana Microschool Collaborative offers one example of what can happen when we stop treating the boundaries between educational sectors as walls. Although it operates as a statewide public charter school, some of its most promising work involves partnering with communities and traditional school corporations to develop small, personalized learning environments. Its value will ultimately be measured not by its label, but by the quality of its schools, the strength of its partnerships, and the outcomes of the students it serves.
Some of its strongest possibilities involve collaboration rather than competition.
The same is true of Aaron’s work to build rural collaboratives. Small school corporations face challenges that are difficult to solve alone. Through collaboration, districts can share ideas, programs, staff expertise, professional learning, and opportunities for students while still maintaining their local identities. These partnerships recognize that serving children well is more important than making sure one organization gets all the credit.
That raises a larger possibility: What might happen if traditional public, public charter, and private-school educators found more ways to collaborate around the shared cause of serving children?
We could learn from one another instead of only lobbying against one another. We could share specialized staff and professional learning. We could build stronger career pathways together. We could help families navigate their options honestly. We could even acknowledge when another school has developed something worth learning from or when a particular student may be better served somewhere else.
None of this means every new school or program deserves automatic support. Choice without quality, access, and accountability is not enough. Every school receiving public dollars should be transparent about its performance, responsible with taxpayer funds, accessible to the students it claims to serve, and able to demonstrate that students are learning.
Choice also has to be more than theoretical. A family does not have a meaningful choice if transportation is unavailable, the nearest option is 40 miles away, the school cannot support a child’s disability, or the family lacks clear information about what the program actually provides. This is especially important in rural communities, where geography and limited resources can make an option available on paper but inaccessible in practice.
But scrutiny should be consistent.
We should not hold one model to a standard we are unwilling to apply to our own programs. We should not assume something is good simply because a district operates it, or bad simply because it does not. And if we believe some students need a different approach, that principle should not change based on whether the program belongs to us.
The most important questions are not who created the option or who receives the enrollment. The questions are: Are students learning? Do they feel known and supported? Are families making an informed choice? Is the program meeting a need that was not being met before?
When a family chooses another option, our first response should not always be defensiveness. Sometimes that decision can reveal something we need to hear: a student did not feel known, a family did not feel heard, or a program did not meet a legitimate need. We may disagree with the choice, but we should still be willing to learn from it.
Public education is bigger than any single institution. Its purpose is not to guarantee that one organization serves every student. Its purpose is to ensure that every student is served well.
Traditional districts should absolutely create new options. We should listen to families, adapt more quickly, and design schools and programs around the students in front of us. Charter and private-school educators should also be willing to learn from the deep expertise, community connections, and commitment found in traditional public schools.
We may discover that we have much more in common than our debates suggest.
Perhaps the clearest test of whether we truly believe in school choice is not how we respond when families choose us.
It is how we respond when they do not. Do we dismiss their decision, attack the alternative, and retreat behind institutional boundaries? Or do we listen, learn, and remain willing to work with anyone committed to serving children well?
School choice becomes meaningful when families have access to quality options, honest information, and educators who care more about where students thrive than about who receives the credit.
About the Authors
George Philhower, Ph.D., is the superintendent of Eastern Hancock Schools, a rural district located just east of Indianapolis. With five years of experience as a superintendent, he is driven by a vision where every student and staff member wakes up eager to go to school each day. He believes this is possible when everyone feels safe and valued, has opportunities for success, engages in meaningful work, plays and learns with friends, and is supported by caring adults.
Aaron Black is the superintendent of Liberty Perry School Corporation in rural Eastern Indiana. He has more than six years of experience leading school districts and was awarded Superintendent of the Year for District #6 in 2024.